With a network of 22 hospitals and more than 2,500 beds, Fortis
Healthcare is one of India’s leading chains of private
hospitals. In July, the company reported its first time net profit
of Rs 94 lakh for the quarter ended June 30, 2008.
The profits may look meager at the moment, but the scale of
operations that the company is fortifying itself for is humongous:
Forty is the number of hospitals that Fortis is targeting by the
end of 2010.
In a scenario where healthcare is
getting better and competitive, the role that technology plays
cannot be overplayed. “One of the first things that my boss
asked me was, ‘How will you cut the paperwork?’”
says CIO Manish Gupta, who has been putting together several IT
initiatives at Fortis’s sprawl of hospitals in order to take
the entire organization to the next level of operational efficiency
and success.
So the first thing Gupta did was to analyze the processes in
different departments of the organization. “We found that
there was a lot of unnecessary paperwork associated with routine
procedures such as moving a patient to another room,” he
says. Gupta suggested several changes to shorten or smoothen
various procedures associated with patient care as well as internal
operations of the company. He also put in place a print management
system through which printing rights were prioritized or reserved
only for those with the most pressing needs – such as for
legal and compliance purposes.
Taking a cue from print management, the next step perhaps would
be to put in place a document management system. However, Gupta is
in favor of taking a cautious approach. Says he, “It may be
easy to just go ahead and implement a DLM (document lifecycle
management) solution but you have to figure out why you need a
DLM.”
Such an analytical approach is critical to examining processes
and implementing change in an organization that has grown through
stitching together several mergers and acquisitions. Citing just
one example of merging Escorts and Fortis systems, Gupta says,
“Technically, the Escorts system and the Fortis system were
on the same platform, but the teams were different, the culture was
different and the behavior of people was different.”
An initiative that Gupta has undertaken in earnest is the
integration of two separate Hospital Management Systems (HMSs)
which, he says, “are fundamentally different.” One is a
home-grown administrative system to ensure that the patients are
properly admitted and discharged and the other is a world-class
third-party clinical system called MedTrak (from TrakHealth, a
subsidiary of Australia-based InterSystems Corp.). Apart from
administration, clinical information such as blood pressure,
temperature, type of allergy, etc. is also captured – what in
healthcare parlance is called EPR or electronic patient record.
“All our new hospitals are running on MedTrak while the
rest run the in-house Hospital Information System (HIS). One of the
experiments we did last year was to migrate the HIS at one of our
oldest hospitals, in Mohali, to MedTrak – including everyone
from doctors and nurses to pharmacist,” says Gupta. The
success of that experiment? “We are realizing that our
hospitals are ready for world-class software.”
Putting the pieces together
A key change that Gupta has brought about is centralization of IT.
“Unlike many other healthcare providers that have their
software teams sitting at individual locations, we have a
centralized team. So any change in software is seen and approved by
the central team,” says Gupta.
As a hospital, we have to collect and keep all the information
we get regarding the patients, says Gupta. Part of this information
is in paper form, which goes to the medical records department, and
part of it is fed into the computers. Fortis is trying to get all
the paper-based information online. “The challenge is that
there’s relatively much less information in our HIS than what
exists on paper.”
There are several ways in which Gupta and his team are trying to
increase the collection and conversion of information into the
digital format. “One is I’m trying to sell the Tablet
PC to our doctors. I’ve gone to them a few times, showing
them how it works and how they can enter information into it
conveniently and they are quite enthusiastic about it. Fortunately,
doctors are a different kind of breed – they like to play
with toys!” says Gupta. So he’s hoping some of the
senior doctors will catch on with the Tablet PCs and then the
younger ones will follow.
Another thing that IT is doing is that the moment new doctors
join, it “catches them right there” – preventing
them from getting into the paper culture. “So I ask my
medical operations group team to expose them to HIS as soon as they
join,” says Gupta.
“The third thing we are doing is putting data entry
operators to digitize patient records,” says Gupta. After key
entry, these records are verified by a doctor who’s
specifically assigned for this task so that the final records are
accurate. Gupta has also enlisted nurses as active participants in
many of his initiatives, as they are IT’s biggest users and
are directly responsible for administering the care to patients
most of the time. Naturally, they have the best knowledge of
patient needs and preferences.
Another challenge Fortis faces is that even though all the
imaging data – generated through scores of X-Ray machines,
MRI scanners, dopplers, etc. – is available in a digital
format and gets recorded in a database, these machines do not talk
to each other as they are from different manufacturers. “What
we want to do is make all images on a patient available to the
doctor in an integrated format,” says Gupta.
There’s a specialized solution called PACS or Picture
Archival and Communication Server at Fortis hospitals, which pulls
out images from all the machines, connects them to the patient and
stores and retrieves them whenever the doctor wants. While bigger
machines have their own database embedded, for X-ray machines
there’s an in-house database application. What PACS does is
aggregate images from this database as well as other
machines’ databases. This is an off-the-shelf package and can
be customized but the challenge, says Gupta, is to implement it in
the right way. For instance, you need to look at the best way to
make the huge bank of images available to doctors within the same
hospital against sending out the images to others posted in
different locations.
Until the complete centralization happens, what Fortis is doing
is storing the images in local hospitals for about five to seven
days or during the hospitalization of the patient – and then
sending those images to a central location for storage, archival
and later retrieval.
Managing complexity
So how does one manage complexity at a ragtag bunch of
hospitals? One way, as Gupta has discovered, is to standardize the
software and the development process. “Over the past one
year, I’ve created a software change control team. Any
hospital that requires a change in their software will have to go
through this central team,” says Gupta. The advantage is that
IT takes inputs from hospitals other than the ones that have
requested a change. If most hospitals concur, then the team
implements the change centrally across all hospitals. At the same
time, if only one or two hospitals want to change, say, the
check-out time for applying room rents, IT can do that as well.
“Such a centralized mode of operation keeps our workload
minimized and our tasks streamlined,” says Gupta.
Regarding the data center, Fortis has a small data center where
it houses its mail server and some other applications, but the
hospital systems are not yet centralized – they are still
running in pockets. “So there’s a need for us to
centralize our applications,” says Gupta. Currently,
there’s a database at each hospital that pulls information in
batch mode from various applications such as patient information
and other high-level data.
Fortis is currently evaluating SAP as an enterprise-wide
software. “Why we felt the need for an SAP is that we
realized that each hospital was running its own set of financial
and inventory software, and the existence of multiple software
– many of which were old and outdated – was impeding
our ability to centralize operations,” says Gupta.
“The business problem we face is how to match SAP’s
inventory controls with the way we administer medicines using our
HIS,” says Gupta. SAP is a very tightly controlled system: it
will not allow the issue of an item from the inventory without
completing all the validations (like batch number, rack number,
location, etc). “However, in a real hospital environment, I
cannot have so many controls because sometimes the system will not
allow a medicine to be issued if some validation condition is not
met; as a result, the patient may suffer,” says Gupta.
While SAP may work in a factory environment, there can be
certain issues with how things work in a hospital setting. For
instance, the pharmacist will give the medicine and think about the
[SAP] system later. Thus, matching the exigencies of the HIS with
the intricacies of ERP is a challenge that must be met if the whole
system is to work smoothly.
Platform for knowledge-sharing
“Another initiative we are undertaking is to roll out our
intranet using Microsoft SharePoint. The portal will have
company-wide information for employees – information like
medical records, paperless processes like leave and clearance
forms, new hires and induction,” says Gupta. The company is
also planning to have knowledge management through SharePoint, in
which employee discussions can happen on the portal. “When I
interacted with doctors I found that everybody is looking for
recognition and research – for instance, publish their papers
in journals. So the challenge is how do we do that, and are they
[doctors] willing to share knowledge with each other?” says
Gupta.
Having a creative bent of mind, Gupta is turned on rather than
put off by challenges. Says he: “Healthcare is an emergency
industry when it comes to facing patients and doctors. So you
cannot drive a lot of things by systems here – it’s not
a factory environment. You have to make things easy for people, for
instance, by ensuring that the screens we give them are very user
friendly and we are able to take care of their usage issues even
through mobile calls.”
Another challenge before Fortis in its attempt to further
rationalize cost and optimize resources is the way accounting and
costing is done in the healthcare business. “In healthcare,
it is very difficult to ensure accounting and costing,” says
Gupta. “Unlike in, say, manufacturing, where there’s a
defined assembly line procedure and I know that there are some
components going into it, there’s electricity going into
it...in our case when a patient comes in, there are two or three
doctors and four-five nurses working on it, there’s room
facilities, there are labs and other things involved…so it
becomes difficult to assess and analyze our cost structure for
different patients and different services we offer to
them.”
In the midst of multiple challenges, Gupta is thinking ahead on
what he’s going to do next. Among the things on the anvil at
Fortis are an MPLS network; biometric authentication of patients;
RFID implementation in select applications; and e-learning tools
for doctors undergoing training.
Surely, as Fortis blazes the trail toward its ambitious goals in
healthcare, Gupta will have a lot on his Tablet.
So how does one manage complexity at a ragtag bunch of
hospitals? One way, as Gupta has discovered, is to standardize the
software and the development process. “Over the past one
year, I’ve created a software change control team. Any
hospital that requires a change in their software will have to go
through this central team,” says Gupta. The advantage is that
IT takes inputs from hospitals other than the ones that have
requested a change. If most hospitals concur, then the team
implements the change centrally across all hospitals. At the same
time, if only one or two hospitals want to change, say, the
check-out time for applying room rents, IT can do that as well.
“Such a centralized mode of operation keeps our workload
minimized and our tasks streamlined,” says Gupta.
“Another initiative we are undertaking is to roll out our
intranet using Microsoft SharePoint. The portal will have
company-wide information for employees – information like
medical records, paperless processes like leave and clearance
forms, new hires and induction,” says Gupta.
The company is also planning to have knowledge management
through SharePoint, in which employee discussions can happen on the
portal. “When I interacted with doctors I found that
everybody is looking for recognition and research – for
instance, publish their papers in journals. So the challenge is how
do we do that, and are they [doctors] willing to share knowledge
with each other?” says Gupta.